A nonprofit news organization covering the U.S. criminal justice system
About
Feedback?
support@themarshallproject.org
Daryl T. Dennie's responses to questions from the community.
Discretion may be the most valuable tool a judge has. Discretion denotes alternatives. I will use my discretion in every decision made to insure I am making the most fair and reasonable ruling or decision on the issue before me.
I strongly promote equal access to justice. I know what bias looks like, and I know the damage caused by it. My decisions will be based on the law as applied with fairness and impartiality.
As a practicing criminal defense attorney, now public defender, I have argued for bond reductions many times. Bonds have gotten better, however there are many instances where a low 10% bond is too much for a client to pay and they sit in county jail because they simply have no money. Yes, we need to consider public safety when setting bonds but there are systems in place to accomplish that end.
This is a great question and I have heard non-lawyers debate the issue of election versus appointment. I believe the election system offers the best opportunity for any person to achieve the dream of becoming a judge. In my opinion, it is the most fair. Let the citizens, who we serve, make the decision.
I find that these programs do work and provide great resolutions for many. I would be open to any programming that offers a person an opportunity to do better where such an option exists.
Frankly, it will be part of the job. In some instances a very difficult part of the job. I will have to trust that my decision is fair, impartial and just.