When Ohio lawmakers passed legislation in late 2024 to eliminate license suspensions and vehicle registration blocks over unpaid fines and fees for traffic infractions, the change brought relief for hundreds of thousands of drivers — except many in Medina Municipal Court.
Court officials had placed registration blocks on nearly 1,700 traffic cases that have not been cleared, according to data provided to The Marshall Project - Cleveland. The blocks prevent drivers from renewing their license plates with the state Bureau of Motor Vehicles, which can lead to new tickets and fines if they continue to drive without proper tags.
Attorneys, legal experts and a state lawmaker said under the law, known as House Bill 29, Medina Municipal Court Judge Gary Werner should have removed all past registration blocks for unpaid fines and fees.
Werner, who has presided over the court since 2017, did not respond to repeated emails, calls and courthouse visits from The Marshall Project - Cleveland to comment about the registration blocks.
State Rep. Darnell Brewer, a Democrat from Cleveland who co-sponsored House Bill 29, said Werner has disrespected the law by keeping the registration blocks in place.
“It is wrong,” Brewer said. “They need to be removed. The Ohio Supreme Court should deal with this judge.”
About 30 miles south of Cleveland, the Medina Municipal Court handles cases for the cities of Medina, Brunswick and 13 villages and townships in northern Medina County.
Medina Clerk of Court Mike Kovac said a state Bureau of Motor Vehicles employee told his office that registration blocks attached before the law went into effect on April 9, 2025, were not subject to it.
“We certainly want to be abiding by the law but, as so often happens with these changes, clear direction can often be difficult to come by,” Kovack wrote in an email.
But attorneys with Legal Aid Society of Cleveland, along with an advisory written last year for the Ohio Judicial Conference by a retired judge, made clear that the law also eliminated past registration blocks for unpaid fines and court costs.
Records show the Medina Municipal Court added nearly 950 registration blocks in traffic cases in the weeks between the law’s passage and its effective date.
The Marshall Project - Cleveland began asking questions about the blocks Monday after a resident complained in a lengthy Facebook post on a Medina community page.
In his post, Andy Mascio vented about the “brick wall” he encountered when visiting the court to request a block be removed for his wife. Mascio said he submitted documents and showed copies of the state law.
An employee told him the judge interpreted the law to mean everything enacted before April 9, 2025, was still active, Mascio wrote.
“They are always right and won't even look at documents or have a discussion,” Mascio wrote. “I was told the only way to do this is hire a lawyer and file a case. WTF is wrong with people? I should be able to speak to someone to bring this to someone's attention.”
A review of the docket in Mascio’s wife’s case shows the court added a registration block on April 8, 2025 — the day before House Bill 29 went into effect, and it also sent the case to a collection agency. The Marshall Project - Cleveland found dozens of other cases where the registration block was filed the same day it was sent to collections.
Commenters on the Facebook post quickly chimed in to share their frustrations about how the court’s interpretation had burdened them for the past 19 months.
Brandon Sterrick, who has a paralyzed left arm, said he has an estimated seven to 10 registration blocks he racked up during a difficult period years ago and that he could not get answers from the court about why they hadn’t been lifted after House Bill 29.
He said he had also encountered hostilities from a staffer when he and his mom tried requesting a hearing before Werner to get details on all his blocks.
“They treat everybody like criminals,” Sterrick said about court staff. “I don’t understand this. Dealing with them has been a nightmare.”
Donna Bartolozzi, Sterrick’s mom, said she witnessed a staff member ridicule her son over his disability. The registration blocks, she said, have also cost her money since she financed her son’s car to keep it in her name.
“As a taxpayer and voter, I’m watching people get ripped off because the court is trying to interpret the law at its own discretion," she said.
Kovack said he was surprised to learn about the frustrations from people visiting the court, and that he takes “customer service very seriously here.” He encouraged people to contact him with complaints.
House Bill 29 was passed following a Marshall Project - Cleveland and News 5 investigation that found the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles issued nearly 200,000 new license suspensions in 2022 for debt-related reasons such as failing to pay court fines or missing child support payments.
After the investigation was published, lawmakers spent months reworking a proposed law to incorporate parts of the news outlets’ findings.
The law brought Ohio in line with neighboring states, such as Indiana, West Virginia and Kentucky, which had eliminated debt-based license suspensions in recent years.
From April 9 to May 9 last year, over 500 courts across Ohio removed more than 272,000 registration blocks and license suspensions, state records show.